Thread: Useing the firearms register

Originally Posted by No.3

This is the point I was making, the system should be flexible enough to cater for the weird and abstract as of right - regardless of the priorities of the people that are doing the software engineering on the thing. This is almost like the pressure cylinder registration system aka the LAB/SP LAB number system. There are so many cases of SP LAB numbers issued where there was already a design approval/LAB number for that cylinder that meant the cylinders should just have been whacked with that number (ignoring the fact that it just invalidated the coating warranty on that cylinder but that's by the by). There are many cases in the LAB register of identical cylinders registered under different LAB numbers due to one or two minor differences in recordings, so the entire thing goes pear shaped as a register due to data crumples.

I can see the registry going bad to worse and ending up being useless in short time just due to the issues mentioned. As I keep saying, I'm not against the idea of a registry provided it is proven secure, is accurate, is cost effective and actually contributes to public safety and what we are seeing so far - doesn't appear to meet any of those tests just due to the way it's been done without subject matter experts involved in the design and development phases and the quality of the supporting infrastructure backing it up.

But have a think, when will it be useful i solving crime? It certainly has benefits for confiscating off the law abiding and putting clamps on same, but solving crime, SFA

Originally Posted by Maca49

But have a think, when will it be useful i solving crime? It certainly has benefits for confiscating off the law abiding and putting clamps on same, but solving crime, SFA

It doesn't have any impact on crime,none at all, It is a instrument of delayed confiscation . Once you register a gun ,you from that moment on simply borrow if from the government until they take it from you at some point in the future.

This has always been a major motivation in firearms registers.

Originally Posted by norsk

It doesn't have any impact on crime,none at all, It is a instrument of delayed confiscation . Once you register a gun ,you from that moment on simply borrow if from the government until they take it from you at some point in the future.

This has always been a major motivation in firearms registers.

I can only hope you’re wrong!

Originally Posted by Finnwolf

I can only hope you’re wrong!

I'm sure that this register is unique in history, and won't be used to enable confiscation.